Book Review
Title: Dutchman’s Fireside
Author: James Kirke Paulding
Publisher: College & University Press
Date: 1966 (first published June 10, 1831)
ASIN: B00QOB429E
Paulding’s 1831 novel has two distinct, overlapping story arcs: In the first, the hero is initiated from awkward boy to confident man who has proven himself through several trials. In the second, the heroine grows from appearance-and-social-status obsessed to a deeper appreciation of character, courage, and integrity. The heroine’s change makes her more appreciative of the hero’s qualities. It helps that he saves her life a few times.
Perhaps the most enjoyable (to me) section of the novel is the hero’s journey to the frontier, where he confronts several life-threatening challenges. He rises to the occasion each time, and each instance strengthens his character.
In a less enjoyable but important section, the hero visits the heroine in New York City, where she socializes in sophisticated circles. When the rural hero comes to visit, she is embarrassed by his manner, his clothes, and his general appearance. Through various experiences she comes to regret her embarrassment and reestablishes their relationship, and in the end they get married.
The storyline offers valuable life lessons, but the real joy in reading this book is Paulding’s style of writing. The æsthetic composition, syntax, and linguistic choices comfort the heart like the warm hearth cited in the title. It is truly a pleasure to read.
The book is not very well known, though it was quite popular in its time. I for one definitely recommend dusting it off. For pleasant light reading with the bonus of some interesting eighteenth-century American Colonial history, the book is a hidden treasure.